Question Details

Personal Interview (PI)

What if I can't understand the panel's question during my CAT 2025 PI?

👤 Asked by Vidit Arya 📅 1 month ago 💬 0 comments
Scared of asking them to repeat or clarify. Will it make me look dumb or unprepared? How do I handle this gracefully?
Prashant Sir

Expert ✓ Verified

Answered 1 month ago

The Fear That Paralyzes Candidates Unnecessarily

Let me tell you about Arjun, one of my students last year. IIM Kozhikode interview. Panelist asked a complex question about monetary policy implications on SME lending. Arjun didn't fully understand it but was terrified of asking for clarification. So he guessed what was being asked and answered something vaguely related. The panelist's response? "That's not what I asked." Arjun's confidence shattered for the remaining 15 minutes. He didn't get selected.

Here's what kills me about this story: asking for clarification would have been PERFECTLY fine. What wasn't fine was answering the wrong question entirely. After 18 years of preparing students for IIM interviews, I can tell you this with certainty - no candidate has ever been rejected for politely asking a panelist to repeat or clarify a question. But hundreds have been rejected for answering something that wasn't asked.

Why Asking for Clarification Shows STRENGTH, Not Weakness

Think about it from the panel's perspective. They're selecting future managers. In real business situations, will you always understand every question, every instruction, every client requirement perfectly the first time? Never. What separates good managers from disasters is the ability to seek clarity BEFORE acting, rather than assuming and messing up.

When you ask for clarification, you're demonstrating exactly this quality. You're saying: "I want to give you a precise answer, and I need to understand your question precisely first." That's not weakness. That's professionalism. That's what IIMs want to see.

The Right Way to Ask (And the Wrong Way)

There's a difference between asking smartly and asking in ways that DO make you look unprepared. Let me break this down.

If you didn't hear the question clearly (accent, speed, or external noise), say: "I'm sorry Sir/Ma'am, I couldn't catch that clearly. Could you please repeat the question?" Simple. Direct. No one will judge you for this - interview rooms can be noisy, accents vary, nerves affect hearing. Completely acceptable.

If you heard the words but didn't understand what's being asked, try: "Just to make sure I understand correctly - are you asking about X or Y?" This shows you're thinking, not zoning out. It also gives the panelist a chance to redirect you if you're heading in the wrong direction.

If the question has multiple parts and you want to ensure you address everything: "That's a comprehensive question. You're asking about A, B, and C - would you like me to address them in that order?" This actually IMPRESSES panelists because it shows structured thinking.

What NOT to do: Don't say "I don't understand" without attempting to identify what's confusing you. Don't ask them to repeat more than twice for the same question. Don't sit in confused silence hoping they'll rephrase automatically.

The 5-Second Rule When You're Unsure

Here's a technique I teach all my students: when you're unsure about a question, take 5 seconds before responding. Use those 5 seconds to ask yourself: "Am I 80% sure what they're asking?" If yes, answer. If no, clarify.

Those 5 seconds also give you time to formulate a smart clarifying question rather than blurting out "Huh?" or "What?" The pause itself looks thoughtful, not confused. Panelists expect you to think before answering complex questions.

What If You Still Don't Understand After Clarification?

Sometimes questions are genuinely outside your knowledge domain. The panelist clarifies, and you realize you simply don't know enough about the topic to answer well. Here's what you do: be honest. Say: "Thank you for clarifying. I don't have deep knowledge about this specific area, but based on my understanding, I would think..." Then give your best logical reasoning.

This is infinitely better than pretending to know something you don't. Panelists can smell fake confidence from a mile away. Honest acknowledgment of limitations, combined with an attempt to reason through the problem, earns respect.

Your Preparation Action Step

In your next mock interview, deliberately ask your friend to throw one complex, jargon-heavy question. Practice your clarification response. Get comfortable with the words. The more you practice asking for clarification in low-stakes situations, the more natural it'll feel when it matters.

Remember: a clarified question answered well beats a misunderstood question answered brilliantly. Every single time.

You've got this. Happy Learning! 🙂

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!